BOOM

Trending Searches

    SUPPORT
    BOOM

    Trending News

      • Fact Check 
        • Fast Check
        • Politics
        • Business
        • Entertainment
        • Social
        • Sports
        • World
      • Law
      • Explainers
      • News 
        • All News
      • Decode 
        • Impact
        • Scamcheck
        • Life
        • Voices
      • Media Buddhi 
        • Digital Buddhi
        • Senior Citizens
        • Videos
      • Web Stories
      • BOOM Research
      • BOOM Labs
      • Deepfake Tracker
      • Videos 
        • Facts Neeti
      • Home-icon
        Home
      • About Us-icon
        About Us
      • Authors-icon
        Authors
      • Team-icon
        Team
      • Careers-icon
        Careers
      • Internship-icon
        Internship
      • Contact Us-icon
        Contact Us
      • Methodology-icon
        Methodology
      • Correction Policy-icon
        Correction Policy
      • Non-Partnership Policy-icon
        Non-Partnership Policy
      • Cookie Policy-icon
        Cookie Policy
      • Grievance Redressal-icon
        Grievance Redressal
      • Republishing Guidelines-icon
        Republishing Guidelines
      • Fact Check-icon
        Fact Check
        Fast Check
        Politics
        Business
        Entertainment
        Social
        Sports
        World
      • Law-icon
        Law
      • Explainers-icon
        Explainers
      • News-icon
        News
        All News
      • Decode-icon
        Decode
        Impact
        Scamcheck
        Life
        Voices
      • Media Buddhi-icon
        Media Buddhi
        Digital Buddhi
        Senior Citizens
        Videos
      • Web Stories-icon
        Web Stories
      • BOOM Research-icon
        BOOM Research
      • BOOM Labs-icon
        BOOM Labs
      • Deepfake Tracker-icon
        Deepfake Tracker
      • Videos-icon
        Videos
        Facts Neeti
      Trending Tags
      TRENDING
      • #Operation Sindoor
      • #Pahalgam Terror Attack
      • #Narendra Modi
      • #Rahul Gandhi
      • #Waqf Amendment Bill
      • #Arvind Kejriwal
      • #Deepfake
      • #Artificial Intelligence
      • Home
      • News
      • Rahul Gandhi's Speech Expunged:...
      News

      Rahul Gandhi's Speech Expunged: Does It Matter In The Digital Age?

      Though Speaker Om Birla expunged portions of Rahul Gandhi's speech from official records, one can still access the uncensored version online.

      By - Ritika Jain |
      Published -  4 July 2024 9:07 PM IST
    • Boomlive
      Rahul Gandhis Speech Expunged: Does It Matter In The Digital Age?

      Speaker Om Birla Expunged Portions Of Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's Maiden Speech

      • Parliamentary proceedings are telecast live on Sansad TV
      • On July 1, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi gave his maiden speech as Leader of Opposition
      • Rule 380 empowers the Speaker to censor defamatory or unparliamentary words
      • Speaker Om Birla directed 14 cuts in Rahul Gandhi's speech
      • LoP Rahul Gandhi said he spoke the truth and it would prevail

      Ever since Speaker Om Birla expunged portions of Rahul Gandhi’s maiden speech in the Lok Sabha as Leader of Opposition, it has been widely debated if such a move is relevant in the digital age where parliamentary proceedings are telecast live via Sansad TV, the official public broadcaster.

      On July 1, Gandhi criticised the ruling party, the RSS, Prime Minister Narendra Modi, made reference to Hindutva and violence, Agnipath scheme, NEET and Manipur among others.

      In all, Speaker Om Birla directed 14 cuts to Gandhi’s speech.

      However, the expunction notice was circulated post-midnight by when the speech was already seen live by millions, was reported by newspapers, debated upon and still is available online for all to read and see in the form of recordings, live tweets, reportage on news channels and digital media.

      “In the digital age, expunction has become somewhat anachronistic, when millions have seen and heard the speech,” Devender Singh Aswal, former additional secretary Lok Sabha told BOOM.

      Case in point, three days later, the uncensored version of Gandhi’s almost 100-minutes-long speech is still available on Sansad TV's official Youtube channel where it has garnered more than 800k views, while the written version of the speech, which forms the official record of the proceedings, can be seen on the Lok Sabha’s official website with the cuts ordered by the Speaker.

      Reacting to the expunction order, Gandhi said he spoke the truth and it would prevail. The Congress leader has appealed for the restoration of his speech, however, the final decision lies with the Speaker.


      LoP @RahulGandhi wrote to LS Speaker @ombirlakota seeking the restoration of his complete speech from his Motion of Thanks on the President's Address suggesting that taking them down in the garb of expunction defies logic & goes against the tenets of democracy. @boomlive_in pic.twitter.com/C7p94vr3pG

      — Ritika Jain (@riotsjain) July 2, 2024

      Also Read: Cropped Video Peddled As Rahul Gandhi Using Expletive Against PM Modi

      Locking the stable after the horse has bolted

      “Censorship is pointless in the age of social media and the internet. To expunge remarks heard by a huge number of people, shared and discussed threadbare makes zero sense. It’s a bit like closing the stable door after the horse has bolted,” Vidya Subrahmaniam, former associate editor, The Hindu said.

      “That said it’s anybody’s guess how long the YouTube tube content will remain in its original form. Public memory being short future researchers may find it difficult to understand precisely what happened on July 1 and 2 of 2024 in the two Houses of Parliament,” Subrahmaniam added.

      According to Rule 380 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha, the Speaker has the discretion to expunge any words or expressions used by an MP/MLA in a debate that they may consider to be defamatory, indecent, unparliamentary, or undignified. The expunged portions of the speech will not reflect in the official records of the Parliament.

      Ex-Secretary General PDT Acharya clarified that it doesn’t matter whether we are in the digital age or not, once a speaker has expunged a speech or a portion of it, one cannot show, share, or disseminate it anywhere.

      Ex-bureaucrat Devender Singh Aswal said, “Anyone who publishes expunged portion can be hauled up for breach of privilege by the House. The rule is based on the powers and privileges of the British House of Commons and recognised by the Indian Constitution.”

      “Printing and circulation of expunged portion remains liable to breach of privilege,” Aswal cautioned. However, senior journalist Arvind Kumar Singh said in this internet age, everyone with a phone has access to the proceedings. “Har aadmi dekh raha hai, sun raha hai (everyone is seeing it, listening to it) so what difference does it make?” He told BOOM.

      “The Speaker’s decision to censor Rahul Gandhi may be a hollow victory and a short gain. Gandhi’s speech was seen live and is already in the public domain, Singh said. “Only the official records will reflect the censored version of his speech,” he added.

      “That is why I say such expunctions are anachronistic. The role of the Speaker becomes a butt of private ridicule. A Speaker must be seen independent and impartial. He is first and foremost a custodian of the rights and privileges of the members,” Aswal told BOOM.

      Also Read: Can't Impose Additional Restrictions on Lawmaker's Right to Free Speech: SC

      Immunity for MP/MLAs during proceedings; elevated right to free speech

      Experts suggest that the right to free speech accorded to a lawmaker “stands on a different footing” than the fundamental right to free speech enjoyed by citizens of this country. “It is their privilege. MPs/MLAs speak for the people they represent,” senior journalist Arvind Kumar Singh said.

      The Indian Constitution protects parliamentarians for what they say on the floor of the house or while conducting house business. However, this is tempered by the aforementioned Rule 380 which gives the Speaker power to censor speeches or language he deems to be unparliamentary or undignified.

      For example, an MP/MLA cannot be prosecuted for what they say during parliamentary proceedings. Courts are also barred from inquiring into what the lawmaker says in Parliament. But their speeches are subject to the Speaker’s sensitivity.

      This, experts said, give MP/MLAs an “elevated” right to free speech.

      However, it is pertinent to point out that parliamentarians enjoy this immunity only in the house. They do not have immunity if they speak outside Lok Sabha or Rajya Sabha. Outside the house, they would be liable to defamation or any other penal laws.

      In January 2023, the Supreme Court Constitution Bench held that one cannot impose additional restrictions on a lawmaker's right to free speech. However, considering the impact they have on the masses, public functionaries and celebrities must be circumspect in what they say in public, the court added.

      Also Read: Claim Of Anjali Birla Clearing UPSC Without Appearing For Exams Is False

      Censorship unusual, rare but increasingly becoming common: Experts

      Bureaucrats and former journalists rue that expunging significant portions of a lawmaker’s speech was unusual and rare. Some said expunging the PM’s speech and that of the Leader of Opposition was “unheard of”.

      “Expunction in this manner was the rarest of the occasion. But now it is routine,” Arvind Kumar Singh said. “In future, those who study the debates of today will not get the references (of a speech that has been expunged in parts), but because we are in the new age of communication, contemporary society will know because everything now is online,” he added.

      “There is a dictionary of unparliamentary words that lists out phrases, expressions and words that are deemed unparliamentary,” senior journalist Anand Sahay told BOOM. Outright use of abusive words, in any language would lead to automatic expunction, he explained. “in such cases, the politician would be warned as well against using unparliamentary language,” he added.

      “Misleading information is also removed by the Chair,” Sahay said. The senior journalist further explained that if information was considered doubtful or incorrect, the politicians were asked to clear doubts or rectify the same. “The tradition was that when stating facts that may not be common knowledge, an MP will authenticate with supporting material. Every effort was made to not present distortions while speaking in the House,” he said.

      Sahay recalled that in all the years he covered Parliamentary proceedings, “instances of expunctions” used to be considered “not common”. “Earlier, MPs themselves were mindful of their language even when they spoke in an impassioned way, and willingly rectified errors as these were typically not made knowingly – a situation so very different from what we see now, Sahay said. “The PM himself constantly makes innuendos and is in need of constant fact-checking,” he added.

      “In the past, the PM's word on facts was deemed to be factual unless there was a slip of the tongue. Not these days. Alas the PM's example is enthusiastically taken up by the rest of the flock,” Sahay said.

      Tags

      Lok SabhaRahul Gandhi
      Read Full Article
      Next Story
      Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
      Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker. Please reload after ad blocker is disabled.
      X

      Subscribe to BOOM Newsletters

      👉 No spam, no paywall — but verified insights.

      Please enter a Email Address
      Subscribe for free!

      Stay Ahead of Misinformation!

      Please enter a Email Address
      Subscribe Now🛡️ 100% Privacy Protected | No Spam, Just Facts
      By subscribing, you agree with the Terms & conditions and Privacy Policy connected to the offer

      Thank you for subscribing!

      You’re now part of the BOOM community.

      Or, Subscribe to receive latest news via email
      Subscribed Successfully...
      Copy HTMLHTML is copied!
      There's no data to copy!