BOOM

Trending Searches

    SUPPORT
    BOOM

    Trending News

      • Fact Check 
        • Fast Check
        • Politics
        • Business
        • Entertainment
        • Social
        • Sports
        • World
      • Law
      • Explainers
      • News 
        • All News
      • Decode 
        • Impact
        • Scamcheck
        • Life
        • Voices
      • Media Buddhi 
        • Digital Buddhi
        • Senior Citizens
        • Resources
      • Web Stories
      • BOOM Research
      • BOOM Labs
      • Deepfake Tracker
      • Videos 
        • Facts Neeti
      • Home-icon
        Home
      • About Us-icon
        About Us
      • Authors-icon
        Authors
      • Team-icon
        Team
      • Careers-icon
        Careers
      • Internship-icon
        Internship
      • Contact Us-icon
        Contact Us
      • Methodology-icon
        Methodology
      • Correction Policy-icon
        Correction Policy
      • Non-Partnership Policy-icon
        Non-Partnership Policy
      • Cookie Policy-icon
        Cookie Policy
      • Grievance Redressal-icon
        Grievance Redressal
      • Republishing Guidelines-icon
        Republishing Guidelines
      • Fact Check-icon
        Fact Check
        Fast Check
        Politics
        Business
        Entertainment
        Social
        Sports
        World
      • Law-icon
        Law
      • Explainers-icon
        Explainers
      • News-icon
        News
        All News
      • Decode-icon
        Decode
        Impact
        Scamcheck
        Life
        Voices
      • Media Buddhi-icon
        Media Buddhi
        Digital Buddhi
        Senior Citizens
        Resources
      • Web Stories-icon
        Web Stories
      • BOOM Research-icon
        BOOM Research
      • BOOM Labs-icon
        BOOM Labs
      • Deepfake Tracker-icon
        Deepfake Tracker
      • Videos-icon
        Videos
        Facts Neeti
      Trending Tags
      TRENDING
      • #Ahmedabad Plane Crash
      • #G7 Summit
      • #Israel-Iran Conflict
      • #Narendra Modi
      • #Rahul Gandhi
      • #Arvind Kejriwal
      • #Deepfake
      • #Artificial Intelligence
      • Home
      • Law
      • What the SC Is Asking About Bihar’s...
      Law

      What the SC Is Asking About Bihar’s Voter Roll And Citizenship Test

      SC is hearing pleas challenging Bihar’s voter roll revision that requires fresh proof of citizenship ahead of the elections in November.

      By -  Ritika Jain
      Published -  10 July 2025 7:43 PM IST
    • Boomlive
      Listen to this Article
      What the SC Is Asking About Bihar’s Voter Roll And Citizenship Test
      • The Supreme Court questions the Election Commission's exclusion of Aadhaar in Bihar's voter roll revision.
      • Petitioners argue that the citizenship test controversy could affect voter disenfranchisement in the upcoming Bihar elections.
      • The Supreme Court questions the Election Commission's exclusion of Aadhaar in Bihar's voter roll revision.

      “Why is Aadhaar not being accepted?” the Supreme Court asked the Election Commission of India (EC) on Wednesday while hearing a batch of petitions challenging the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls ahead of the Bihar Assembly elections.

      The question struck at the heart of growing concerns that the SIR—meant to clean up the voter list—is being used to unfairly demand proof of citizenship from voters, especially the poor and marginalised. The court was particularly critical of the EC’s decision to exclude widely-used identity documents like Aadhaar, ration cards, and even voter ID cards from the list of accepted documents in the revision process.

      “If you have a good reason to discard Aadhaar (as an acceptable document), you do it—give reasons,” the bench told the EC, as it acknowledged that the Aadhaar is often the foundational document for many other IDs.

      Though the court appreciated the EC’s intent behind conducting the SIR, it was hesitant to halt the process altogether. However, SC raised serious concerns about the way it was being conducted—particularly the timing, and how closely it was tied to the upcoming Bihar elections.

      “We are not stopping you. Do your work, but do it as mandated by the law,” the bench said.

      During the hearing on July 10, the Supreme Court said the petitions raised “important questions which goes to the very root of the functioning of democracy in the country – the right to vote.” It flagged three issues, asking the Election Commission to respond by July 21.

      1. Is the Election Commission empowered to undertake the exercise;
      2. The procedure and the manner in which the exercise is being undertaken, and;
      3. The timing, including the timings given for the preparation of the draft electoral roll.


      The matter will be heard next on July 28.

      Also Read: Bihar’s Voter List Is Being Revised. Who Might Be Left Out?

      What is the SIR and why is it causing alarm?

      The Special Intensive Revision of Bihar’s voter list—underway for the first time since 2003—is meant to weed out duplicate entries, migrants, and deceased voters. But critics say the process is far from routine.

      Multiple petitions before the Supreme Court argue that the SIR is “arbitrary,” “absurd,” and “unconstitutional.” One of the biggest red flags? Even verified voters whose names already exist in the 2003 “Mother Roll” must re-submit proof of citizenship through Enumeration Forms and fresh documents. Yet, Aadhaar, ration cards, and voter IDs—documents held by millions—are not accepted.

      Petitioners, including MPs like Manoj Jha, Supriya Sule, Mahua Moitra, Yogendra Yadav, KC Venugopal, and organisations like the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), argue that this will lead to the mass deletion of genuine voters—many of whom may be unable to meet the document demands in the short window provided.

      Among them, at least two MPs—Mahua Moitra and Thol Thirumavalavan—have challenged the SIR to “preempt” similar disenfranchisement in West Bengal and Tamil Nadu, which are scheduled to go to polls next year.

      BJP leader Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay has also filed a plea. However, he supports the SIR saying it’s the government and poll panel’s “duty” to conduct Special Intensive Revisions of voter lists and “give a strong message” that India “is determined to fight against illegal infiltration”.

      “Executive action should be taken to warn corrupt people who help infiltrators that betrayal of public trust will no longer be tolerated”, Upadhyay’s plea before the Supreme Court states.

      A recent BOOM report highlighted how voters—some of whom have been casting their ballots for decades—are now at risk of being excluded from the rolls.

      Also Read: Did Congress Hand Out Sanitary Pads With Rahul Gandhi’s Photo Inside?

      Is this a citizenship test disguised as a voter list clean-up?

      This is the question at the heart of the petitions. Several lawyers and lawmakers argue that the SIR is essentially a backdoor attempt at creating a National Register of Citizens (NRC)—something that has already sparked controversy in Assam.

      “This is actually an exercise to do citizenship screening,” senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi told the court.

      One of the pleas—filed by the Association of Democratic Reforms (ADR)—suggested that the “ECI has shifted the onus of being on the voters’ list from the State to citizens.” Senior advocate Kapil Sibal supported this view, saying it should be the state’s responsibility to prove that someone is not a citizen—not the other way around.

      However, this burden falls heaviest on Bihar’s poor, marginalised communities, and the migrants - many of whom don’t have access to the EC’s list of “acceptable” documents. According to lawyers, more than 87 per cent of Bihar’s population has Aadhaar cards. So why isn’t that enough?

      The EC defended its decision by stating that Aadhaar is “not proof of citizenship”. But the court pushed back, saying only the government can decide someone’s citizenship through proper legal channels—and that too under the jurisdiction of the Home Ministry, not the Election Commission.

      However, EC said citizenship was one of the requisites to vote in India, as such, Aadhar, which is not a “proof of citizenship” could not be an acceptable document.

      “If citizenship is a mandate under the Representation of the People Act, 1950, you can conduct this exercise independent of the election process,” the court told the EC. “You can do this exercise to see non-citizens are not on the rolls,” the court said, but made it clear that citizenship determination should not be conflated with election preparations.

      Also Read: Locked For Years: A New Life For Assam Residents As They Finally Get Aadhaar Cards

      Can the EC finish the SIR on time?

      Another major concern is the timeline. The EC has given itself just 90 days to complete the SIR—a deadline petitioners say is unrealistic, especially in a state like Bihar.

      The Supreme Court, too, was sceptical. “You should’ve acted earlier. Isn’t it too late now for that?” the bench asked. “There is nothing wrong in having this intensive process so that non-citizens don’t remain on rolls—but it should be de hors (independent of) this election which is coming up.”


      Tags

      Supreme Court Of Indiabihar state electionsElection Commission of IndiaCitizenship Amendment Act
      Read Full Article
      Next Story
      Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
      Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker. Please reload after ad blocker is disabled.
      X

      Subscribe to BOOM Newsletters

      👉 No spam, no paywall — but verified insights.

      Please enter a Email Address
      Subscribe for free!

      Stay Ahead of Misinformation!

      Please enter a Email Address
      Subscribe Now🛡️ 100% Privacy Protected | No Spam, Just Facts
      By subscribing, you agree with the Terms & conditions and Privacy Policy connected to the offer

      Thank you for subscribing!

      You’re now part of the BOOM community.

      Or, Subscribe to receive latest news via email
      Subscribed Successfully...
      Copy HTMLHTML is copied!
      There's no data to copy!