India Today, The Tribune and India TV published a fictional short story about a 55-year-old teacher being harassed and abused by his students in an online class as real incident. The media outlets picked up the story, viral on social media and published it to highlight troubles faced by teachers holding online classes during the Coronavirus-led lockdown in the country.
BOOM found that the story originated from a Facebook post by a Bangladeshi user who clearly mentions at the end of the post that he wrote a fictional story to show solidarity with teachers who face online harassment during classes.
India Today , The Tribune , India TV and the International Business Times ran the story along with an image of a middle-aged man taking a class on Zoom video calling app. While the IB Times has issued a correction in their story, making it clear that it was fictional, the others are yet to do the same.
"Suddenly an unknown ID started using slang at him, the F word, the A word, open threats. He couldn't understand how should he react, he shouted out of anger and embarrassment, a teacher is being humiliated infront of his students. His life work of earning respect from his students seemed to vanish in seconds. His daughter taught him to mute students but the student could unmute himself, the student kept on using slangs and he did it for entertainment. The only thing the teacher could do was to end the class, as he has no choice," India Today wrote, citing an Instagram post.
The story came at a time when the pandemic has forced classes to shift to online video conferences and there have been reported instances of teachers complaining about harassment and even stalking, by students.
NEWS OUTLETS CITE INSTAGRAM POST The India Today article attributed the story and the image to a Instagram page, Ted The Stoner, which has a following of over 1.4 million users. The page had shared the story with the photo on June 16. 2020 crediting it to a Facebook user, Syed Mohamad Fahim. This Instagram post does not mention that the Facebook post is fictional story and not real.
While the Facebook post does not have a photo, the Instagram post added a picture which was later picked up and published by the news outlets too.
Ted The Stoner had later edited the caption to reflect that fact that it is a fictional story.
View this post on Instagram
This definitely deserved a share. Read,understand, implement. Trolling ≠ bullying(This is aFictional story for those asking) Principal suddenly called the 55 year old teacher and told him to learn how to take class online. He doesn't have much to say as he knows that if he denies he will be laid off, at this age in this situation he can't do any other job, to pay for his family he has no choice. Unwillingly he takes his smart phone to his daughter. His daughter helped him to understand the basic of Zoom, his hands often shake to go around the tabs, he often freezes trying to understand how this thing works but he has no choice. The next day he goes to a market to buy a new white board. The price of these small board soared up, but without these how can he take the class? He took the board in a rickshaw and came home. Placed the board in a chair and started practicing the lesson. It was harder than he thought, staring at a camera and teaching but he has no choice. The next day he wore a new shirt, will be seeing his students after one and half month, his daughter helped him to setup the smart phone, and the students were added and the class went on. He was shaky, his voice cracked every now and then he was nervous but he has no choice. Suddenly an unknown ID started using slang at him, the F word, the A word, open threats. He couldn't understand how should he react, he shouted out of anger and embarrassment, a teacher is being humulated infront of his students. His life work of earning respect from his students seemed to vanish in seconds. His daughter taught him to mute students but the student could unmute himself, the student kept on using slangs and he did it for entertainment. The only thing the teacher could do was to end the class, as he has no choice. He called for his daughter, she came running and saw her father in tears, she held him tightly tried to calm him down but he kept crying as he never faced such humiliation in his life. That he had troubled sleeping that night, as he knew the next day he has to wake up and face the same ordeal as he has no choice. Note:Abusing a teacher doesn't make you cool, It makes you sick. Credits: Syed Mohamad Fahim/FB
A post shared by Ted The Stoner (@tedthestoner) on Jul 15, 2020 at 10:14pm PDT
FACT CHECK
BOOM found that the story published by the news outlets is not a real incident and in fact a short fictional story written by a Bangladesh based teacher to highlight the online harassment faced by teachers in an online classroom.
A keyword search on Facebook for Syed Mohammad Fahim led us to the Facebook profile which first put up the story on June 30, 2020. The author, Fahim's post was uploaded on June 30, 2020 where he clearly mentions that it is a fictional story.
The story describes in detail how a 55-year-old teacher was harassed by his students during an online class, where he was abused and threatened and humiliated. The post ends with a disclaimer , "I write this fictional story in solidarity to all teachers who are victims of Zoom bombing by shameless students" making it clear that it is not a true incident.
News outlets published the story with a photo, seemingly a screenshot of an online class showing a teacher, in a bid to show that the teacher in the picture is the one mentioned in the story. We also ran a reverse image search of the viral photo, which led us to another Facebook video posted by a Bangladeshi user called Hafiz R Rahman on July 11, 2020.
The video shows a teacher taking a class on Zoom, which keeps getting disrupted by students, visibly upsetting the teacher. According to Rahman, the teacher's name is Mohiuddin who is taking a class at the Milestone College at Dhaka. BOOM could not independently verify the claims made by Rahman about the video.
