Several Facebook posts claiming a female doctor in Uttar Pradesh died after being injured during stone pelting by local Muslims who refused to be screened for COVID-19, are false as the photo is of a pharmacist from Madhya Pradesh who died of a brain hemorrhage.
A picture of a woman lying in a hospital bed with an intubation tube in her mouth, has gone viral on social media with false claims giving the incident a communal angle.
A caption with the image claims that the woman - now deceased, was a doctor who was injured during stone pelting by Muslims in a village in Uttar Pradesh where she had gone to screen suspected COVID-19 patients.
A Hindi caption with the viral post reads, 'Friends, there's a sad news. Doctor Vandana Tiwari is no more. She had gone to Uttar Pradesh last week to screen patients for Coronavirus but Jihadis attacked her and left her grievously injured. A warrior who had been fighting to save the lives of others lost her after battling death for seven days. Condolences'.
(Hindi: मित्रों दुखद खबर डॉक्टर वंदना तिवारी जी कि मृत्यु हो गई | वह पिछले हफ्ते ही यूपी के एक गाँव में कोरोना टेस्ट के लिए गई थी? लेकिन जिहादीयों ने उन पर हमला करके गंभीर रूप से घायल कर दिया था! लोगों के जीवन बचाने में जुटी एक योद्धा पिछले सात दिन से अपना जीवन बचाने के लिए मौत से लड़ रही थी पर वो हार गई!! भावपूर्ण श्रद्धाजंली |)
Cick here for an archived version of the post.
मित्रों दुखद खबर डॉक्टर वंदना तिवारी जी की मृत्यु हो— Pramod Singh (@pksingh4981) April 9, 2020
वह पिछले हफ्ते ही यूपी के एक गाँव में कोरोना टेस्ट के लिए गई थी?
लेकिन उन पर #हमला करके गंभीर रूप से घायल कर दिया गया था!
लोगों के जीवन बचाने में जुटी एक #योद्धा पिछले सात दिन से अपना जीवन बचाने के लिए मौत से लड़ रही थीं😭 pic.twitter.com/T3VwHb6btX
The misleading post is viral on Twitter and Facebook.
The viral post has confused another incident in Indore, Madhya Pradesh where a five-member team of health officials was attacked on April 2, 2020 when they were visited Tat Patti Bakhal area in Indore to screen patients for the Coronavirus. According to an Outlook report, two women doctors from the team had sustained injuries to their legs.
BOOM ran a reverse image search on the viral picture and found several news reports carrying the same image.
An article in Bhopal Samachar reported that the woman in the picture, Vandana Tiwari, was a pharmacist at the District Medical College, Shivpuri, Madhya Pradesh. The article further mentioned that Tiwari was admitted to Birla Hospital, Gwalior, on April 1, 2020 where she died on April 7. Brain hemorrhage was stated as the cause of her death. Tiwari had reportedly tested negative for coronavirus.
The news reports mentioned that Tiwari had been looking after COVID-19 patients in the Shivpuri hospital. Meanwhile, the dean of the hospital Ila Gujariya told BOOM that Tiwari was on duty till March 31 in the medical college. "We don't have much information about her treatment as she was admitted in Gwalior. She has been absent from duty from April 1," the dean told BOOM.
We also got in touch with the doctor who had treated Tiwari at the Birla Hospital in Gwalior, and he confirmed that the woman in the viral picture was Vandana Tiwari. However, the doctor refused to give us any other details about the patient.
Going by the dean's statement, Vandana was working at the district hospital in MP till March 31, and on April 1, she had been reportedly admitted to a hospital in Gwalior.
The timeline of events shows that the claim that Tiwari was attacked by Muslims in a UP village, are false.
In an incident of violence reported from Muzzafarnagar, UP, a sub-inspector and a constable were grievously injured when a police team trying to enforce lockdown was attacked by a group of villagers on April 1. Read more about it here. This incident did not involve an attack on medics.
BOOM then contacted Superintendent of Police, Shivpuri, Rajesh Chandel, who rubbished the viral claim.
The SP told BOOM that the claim was absolutely false. "She was deployed at the Shivpuri hospital. She was not involved in the Corona treatment. She suffered from a brain hemorrhage and died in Birla hospital in Gwalior. A brain surgery was also performed at the Gwalior hospital," Chandel told BOOM.
BOOM also came across a tweet on UP Police's official fact check handle which denied that Vandana Tiwari's death had any connection with Uttar Pradesh.
भ्रामक सूचना न फैलाएं !— UPPOLICE FACT CHECK (@UPPViralCheck) April 9, 2020
समाचार स्रोतों (https://t.co/9eq33NpFyK …) से विदित है कि वंदना तिवारी जी की घटना का सम्बन्ध मध्य प्रदेश से है , उत्तर प्रदेश में इनसे जुडी ऐसी कोई घटना नहीं हुई है|@agrapolice : सूचनार्थ एवं आवश्यक कार्यवाही हेतु|#UPPAgainstFakeNews https://t.co/Z5C6jum6bs
Madhya Pradesh government's PR department has also tweeted a statement issued by the chief medical and health officer's office, Shivpuri, regarding Vandana Tiwari's death. The statement nowhere mentions about the stone pelting incident as claimed in the viral posts.
इस प्रकरण के सम्बंध में CMHO कार्यालय, शिवपुरी ने जानकारी दी है कि श्रीमती वंदना तिवारी जी को बिरला हॉस्पिटल में ब्रेन हेमरेज डायग्नोस किया गया। 7 अप्रैल को उनका दुःखद निधन हो गया। हॉस्पिटल ने उनकी कोरोना संक्रमण की रिपोर्ट निगेटिव पाई। pic.twitter.com/KJDq4tNkvi— Jansampark MP (@JansamparkMP) April 8, 2020
Incidents of violence against doctors, health and police officials have been reported from across the country recently. At several places, including Uttar Pradesh, teams of doctors have been attacked by agitated members of the public while they tried to screen them for the novel Coronavirus. Police teams have been attacked at some places while they were trying to enforce lockdown in certain areas.
The misleading post is the latest example of misinformation targeting Indian Muslims after after several people who took part in a religious congregation of the Tabligh-e-Jamaat''s Markaz in Nizamuddin West in Delhi in March, tested positive for the coronavirus. BOOM has debunked several such false posts.
Also Read False: Video Shows Muslim Man Spitting On Bread To Spread Coronavirus
Updated On: 2020-04-09T18:31:18+05:30
Claim Review : Photo of doctor who succumbed to injuries sustained during stone pelting by Muslims
Claimed By : Social media
Fact Check : False
. 📧 📣 📝