A series of old and misleading videos and images involving a few churches in Karnataka’s (Mangaluru) Mangalore region have been viral on WhatsApp and social media following the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) victory in the recently concluded assembly election.
Social media posts like the one below claim that BJP and Sangh cadres attacked a church in Mangaluru and tried to plant BJP flags to celebrate the party’s victory. The video, which was posted to Twitter on May 16, was posted by one Mohammed Mohsin who appears to be a supporter of the Congress party.
Bjp and sanghi cadres attacked church in Mangalore to install bhagwa and bjp flags and celebrate victory of bjp majority
Police arrested all of them. pic.twitter.com/d5XWGo4Iop
— Mohammed Mohsin (@dimohsin) May 16, 2018
However, a fact-check revealed that the video is nearly ten years old and shows the outer facade of Saint Sebastian church in Permannur, Mangaluru. A YouTube clip with TV9’s logo shows similar visuals of police rounding up people and making them sit on the ground, as seen in the tweet.
The video is from when relations between the state’s Hindu and Christian communities hit their lowest point. Between August 2008 to September 2008 over two dozen churches and several Christian prayer halls were attacked and vandalized in Udupi, Chikmagalur and Dakshina Kannada districts allegedly by Bajrang Dal activists as backlash for a Hindu religious leader killed in the state of Odisha. (source, source, source) The attacks coincided when the BJP, led by BS Yeddyurappa came to power in Karnataka. While a fact-finding comission set up by the BJP state government to investigate the attacks went on to exonerate Bajarang Dal activists, a successive Congress government that came to power in 2013 went on to reject the commission’s report. (source)
BOOM cannot independently verify the incidents that took place in 2008.
A separate clip showing police storm St Sebastian church has gone viral on Facebook. However, the same sequence of events can be seen in an Al Jazeera news report from 2008.
“No attacks on any church in Mangalore have taken place till Thursday morning. The video going around on social media is very old, nearly ten years old. This is incorrect information,” Marcel Monteiro, public relations officer of the Mangalore Diocese told BOOM.
A fact reiterated by local police in Mangaluru.
Mangaluru Police Commissioner Vipul Kumar told BOOM that there had been no incident reported of vandalizing or attack on any religious structure in the city. He said, “No church was attacked in the city or in the outskirts. Such an incident would have definitely reached the ears of the police force. This rumour is the work of some miscreants,” Kumar said.
FACTS BEHIND THIS VIRAL IMAGE
A separate image showing supporters of the BJP in front of another church are also being circulated on social media. The image is being shared with an implied context that the celebrations were intended to send a message to the local Christian community.
*St . Lawrence chu💒rch*
*BJP* started their *”game”*
after their *”victory”*…???
they can get with a *victory….???*
Sad *”challenging”* days
— samuel (@samuel5565) May 17, 2018
Through a Google Image search BOOM confirmed that the picture was of Saint Lawrence Church in Bondel, Mangaluru.
Marcel Monteiro of Mangalore Diocese told BOOM that while supporters of the party were near church premises no untoward incident took place. “The BJP workers had burst some crackers in front of the St Lawrence Church gate on the day of the election verdict but no trouble was created,” Monteiro said.
NOW, A ‘LINGAYAT CHURCH’? NO, THAT’S JUST PHOTOSHOP
A third image claims to show that the Christian community in Karnataka has built a ‘Lingayat Church’. However, the image is poorly photoshopped and even misspells the word ‘Lingayat’ adding the alphabet ‘h’ to it.
BOOM did a Google Reverse Image search and traced the photo to a blog called ‘Beautiful Indian Churches’ which revealed that the photo is actually of Our Lady of Dolours church in Dahanu, Maharashtra. (see below) The images of the church were posted to the blog in 2012.This is not the first time fake news linking ‘Lingayats and Christians’ has surfaced. BOOM debunked two fake letters separately that allegedly a sinister conspiracy to convert Lingayats in the state to Catholicism. (Read more about it here and here)