A set of two images purported to show that Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) Students' Union president Aishe Ghosh was faking a hand injury, is false. BOOM found that one of the images had been flipped to falsely claim that Ghosh was photographed with different hands being bandaged on two different occasions.
JNU students came under an attack by a mob of masked men and women on January 5 evening. Several students, teachers and staff of the varsity were injured as the unidentified mob went about ransacking the premises and beating them.
Images of an injured Ghosh are doing the rounds with the caption, "You will not know, when the bandage from the left hand will jump to the right hand." (Original text in Bengali: কখন যে বাম হাতের ব্যাণ্ডেজ লাফ মেরে দেন হাতে চলে আসবে আপনি ধরতে পারবেন না )
#LeftBehindJNUViolence
— Shrikant (@ShrikantGayki) January 10, 2020
Aishe Gosh is bigger actor then our Bollywood diva
Another comedy of error by the left thugs
Plaster/Bandage with a sling is shifting arms faster than the Main Stream Media can come with sham-confession tapes. pic.twitter.com/NW7ReZTlsB
Shefali Vaidya tweets mirror image of Aishe Ghosh with false claim
Swarajya columnist Shefali Vaidya tweeted the same mirror image of Aishe Ghosh, along with another, where she can be seen wearing a bandage on her left forearm. Vaidya took a dig at filmmaker Anurag Kashyap for not 'coaching students on continuity.'
Alhamleninallah! It is a miracle. Aishee Ghosh's broken hand got healed in a day and got broken again! @anuragkashyap72 couldn't you coach these dingbats in continuity? pic.twitter.com/oVbgftyLCM
— Shefali Vaidya (@ShefVaidya) January 10, 2020
Kashyap in turn hit back with a mirrored image of Vaidya.
यह हैं भक्त । एक फ़ोटो को horizontally flip कर के continuityसिखा रहे हैं । किसी भी फ़ोन पे हो सकता है मैडम । VFX सीख लो ज़्यादा अच्छा काम करोगे https://t.co/sY0387HolR pic.twitter.com/G6sNbbaZhs
— Anurag Kashyap (@anuragkashyap72) January 10, 2020
FACT CHECK
BOOM was able to ascertain that one of the images in the collage had been flipped in a 180 degree angle and is a mirror image of the original. We were able to find the original image, where Ghosh can be seen addressing students, a day after the attack. The image was clicked by photojournalist Vipin Kumar, of Hindustan Times for Getty Images.
Below is a comparison of both the images, which shows that they are the same. The text in the background has been inverted in the flipped photograph.
BOOM also found a Facebook Live video from January 6, when Ghosh was addressing the varsity students. At 0.28 second mark onward, Ghosh can be seen speaking with a left arm injury.