Is Kerala The Progressive Utopia We Think It Is? A Data FactCheck
The above info-graphic meant as a befitting reply to an Indian news channel for referring to Kerala as ‘Thundery Pakistan’, claims the southern state tops a number of social indicators.
The graphic shared by many on Twitter, including Shashi Tharoor, Member of Parliament for Thiruvananthapuram, makes a total of 24 claims about Kerala’s progress.
Earlier this month, Times Now apologised for referring to Kerala as ‘Thundery Pakistan’ after receiving a backlash on social media from angry Malayalees. (Read our story here)
BOOM decided to fact-check the info-graphic based on publicly available data. While we realize that the graphic was made as a hasty rebuttal and plays on Indian news TV channels’ obsession with superlatives, our analysis shows that although Kerala ranks highly in a number of crucial parameters it does not always top the charts.
CLAIM 1 : No. 1 state in literacy in India
Fact : True. Kerala is the most literate state in the country.
Kerala ranked first with literacy rates of 90.86% in 2011 and 93.91% in 2001.
In contrast, India’s literacy rate was 64.84% in 2011 and 74.04% in 2001.
Literacy is broadly defined as the ability to read and write with understanding in any language.
Source : Niti Aayog
CLAIM 2: No. 1 state in health indexes in India
Fact : True. Kerala leads in key health indices
Life Expectancy: Kerala had the highest life expectancy of 74.9 years among Indian states between 2010-14. Life expectancy for the entire country was at 67.9 years during the corresponding period.
Source : Sample Registration System data (SRS)
Infant Mortality Rate: Between 2011 to 2013 Kerala had the least number of infant deaths in India with an infant mortality rate of 12 out of 1,000 live births in each of those years. Infant mortality rate of India during the corresponding period was 44 (2011), 42 (2012) and 40 (2013)
Source : Niti Aayog
Maternal Mortality Rate: Kerala recorded the lowest maternal deaths of 61 per 1,00,000 live births according to the maternal mortality report of 2011 to 2013. The corresponding number for India was 167 deaths per 1,00,000 live births.
Niti Aayog plans to introduce a ‘Performance on Health Outcomes’ Index for states by September 2017 which shall account for many more health indicators.
Source : Niti Aayog
CLAIM 3 : No. 1 state in human life indexes in India
Fact : No such index exists
If the intended claim was about the Human Development Index (HDI), Kerala had an HDI score of 0.91 which was the highest in India, in 2011-12, according to the latest available data. Kerala is followed by Goa with a score of 0.803 during the same year.
Human development index is a composite index that accounts for factors such as education, health and per capita income of the population.
CLAIM 4 : No. 1 state in gender equality in India
Fact: False. There is no official indicator to measure gender equality in India but a Mckinsey report ranked Kerala third in female empowerment.
Consultancy firm Mckinsey developed a news score called Femdex – Female Empowerment Index in its report, ‘The Power Of Parity: Advancing Women’s Equality’, in November 2015.
Mizoram topped the list with a score of 0.7 out of 1 followed by Meghalaya with 0.69. Kerala stood 3rd with a Femdex score of 0.67. India’s overall score was 0.54.
The index considers 10 indicators that measures gender parity and women empowerment which includes labour force participation, women leadership, maternal mortality rate, sex ratio, child marriage etc.
Source : Mckinsey Global Institute
CLAIM 5 : No. 1 state in sex ratio in India
Fact: Mostly true. Kerala has the best sex ratio, but only the 7th best child sex ratio in India.
According to Census of India, the sex ratio and child sex ratio of Kerala and India is as follows:
|Sex Ratio||Child Sex Ratio||Sex Ratio||Child Sex Ratio|
Sex ratio is the number of females per 1000 males of the population. Child sex ratio is the number of girls per 1000 boys aged 0-6 years.
Though Kerala has the best sex ratio in the country, in terms of child sex ratio Kerala stood 7th in 2011. Mizoram (971) stood 1st, followed by Meghalaya (970).
CLAIM 6: No. 1 state in primary education in India
Fact: There is no overall ranking for primary education in India
However, in the Educational Development Index 2014-15 for primary level, Kerala ranked 36th in the component of Access, 8th in Infrastructure, 4th in Teacher and 30th in Outcome among 35 states and union territories in India.
Refer to the table below which lists indicators used in computing the Educational Development Index.
CLAIM 7 : No. 1 state in lowest child death rate in India
Fact: True. Kerala has the lowest child mortality or under-5 mortality rate in India.
Kerala’s under-5 mortality rate in 2015 was 9 /1,000 live births and in 2014 it was 13 / 1,000 live births. The corresponding figures for India was 29 and 55.
Source : Niti Aayog
CLAIM 8 : No. 1 state in lowest pregnant mothers death in India
Fact: There are no statistics for death of pregnant women.
‘Death of pregnant mothers’ is a vague statement which could include deaths of pregnant women out of reasons other than complications related to pregnancy and child birth.
However, Kerala has the lowest maternal mortality deaths in the country. Maternal mortality ratio gives the number of maternal deaths per 1,00,000 live births during pregnancy or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy.
Kerala has the lowest maternal mortality ratio (MMR) in India, according to a Lok Sabha Question in March 2017.
|MMR per 1,00,000 live birth
|MMR per 1,00,000 live birth
Source : RGI – Sample Registration System
CLAIM 9 : No. 1 state in transgender rights in India
Fact: True. Kerala is the first state in the country to have a Transgender Policy
The Transgender Policy 2015 enables the enforcement of constitutional rights of transgenders following the Supreme Court’s 2014 judgement of recognising a ‘third gender’.
CLAIM 10: No. 1 state in least corrupted state in India
Fact : Kerala was the second least corrupt state, according to the Centre for Media Studies.
Less than 4% of households in Kerala said they experienced corruption in public services according to a study conducted by the Centre for Media Studies. The study covered 20 states. The study found that in Kerala and Himachal Pradesh, households experienced corruption in single digits – 4% and 3%, respectively.
Source : CMS
CLAIM 11: No 1. Tourist destination in India
Fact: False. Tamil Nadu and not Kerala had the highest number of foreign and domestic tourist visitors in 2015.
Tamil Nadu stood first by attracting 20.1% of foreign tourists followed by Maharashtra with 18.9%, according to India Tourism Statistics 2015. Kerala was 7th most preferred destination for foreign tourists in India with a share of 4.2%.
Kerala was not among the top ten destinations for domestic tourists in 2015. Tamil Nadu had the highest share of domestic tourists (23.3%) in the year 2015 followed by Uttar Pradesh with 14.3%.
Source : Ministry of Tourism
CLAIM 12: No. 1 state in foreign remittance in India
Fact: True. Kerala receives highest share of remittance (40%) in the country
It is widely known that Kerala is a highly remittance dependent state. According to an IIM report, ‘Remittances in India: Facts and Issues’, Kerala received (40%) the highest share of remittance in India. Followed by Punjab with 12.7% and Tamil Nadu with 12.4%. The report cites 2007-2008 data.
Source : IIM report, ‘Remittances in India: Facts and Issues’
CLAIM 13: No. 1 state in modern roads in all villages
Fact: False. Karnataka leads in road connectivity while Kerala ranks 7th
Karnataka leads with 99% of habitations connected, followed by Punjab (98.2%), Gujarat (98.1%), Tamil Nadu (97%) and Tripura (91%) under Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana up to February 2017. Kerala (87%) stands 7th in terms of habitation coverage.
‘Habitation is a cluster of population, living in an area, the location of which does not change over time’ and as recorded by the 2001 census.
Source : Lok Sabha Question – March 2017
CLAIM 14: No 1. state in human rights in India
Fact: We are not exactly sure what was intended by the claim
However, number of human rights violations registered in states with Human Rights Commission could shed light on the situation.
Rate of human rights violations refers to the number of such cases registered against 1,00,000 population (as of Census 2011).
In 2016-17, Nagaland (0.61) recorded the least rate of human rights violation, followed by Sikkim and Assam, according to a Lok Sabha Question in March 2017.
Rate of human rights violations registered in Kerala was 2.01 in 2016-17 (according to data till March 5, 2017) and 2.99 in 2015-16.
Delhi (35.32) followed by Uttar Pradesh (20.14) in 2016-17 had the highest rates of human rights violations.
Source : Lok Sabha Question – March 2017
CLAIM 15: No. 1 state in religious tolerance in India
Fact: False. Kerala recorded 13 communal incidents between 2014 – 2016, but there are other states that had none.
According to Lok Sabha Question, Indian states of Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland and Sikkim did not record any communal incidents.
Source : Lok Sabha Question – February 2017
CLAIM 16: No. 1 state for free education for all in India
Fact : False. Except Jammu & Kashmir, all states implement the Right To Education
According to The Right Of Children To Free And Compulsory Education Act (RTE), 2009, every child of the age of 6 -14 years has a right to free and compulsory education in a neighbourhood government school till completion of elementary education (Ist to VIIIth grade). It extends to the entire country, except for Jammu and Kashmir. According to a Lok Sabha question, all states other than Jammu and Kashmir are implementing RTE Act, 2009.
Also, only 45% of school going children of the age 6-14 go to government schools in rural Kerala. The number is the highest for Tripura (89.1%) followed by Odisha (88.9%) and Gujarat (87.4%), according to Annual Status of Education Report 2016 by Pratham. It is a rural household survey on children’s schooling status and outcomes.
CLAIM 17: No. 1 state for free health care for all in India
Fact: Sikkim and not Kerala had the highest per capita health expenditure by a state in 2014-15 and 2013-14.
Kerala spent Rs. 1437 and Rs. 1033 per person on heath in 2014-15 and 2013-14, respectively, according to National Health Profile released by Central Bureau of Health Intelligence. Among Indian states, Sikkim (Rs. 5,666) spent the highest followed by Arunachal Pradesh (Rs. 5,196) 2013-14. In the same year, Bihar (Rs. 530) spent the least.
However, it is important to note that despite not having the highest per capita health expenditure, Kerala still leads in major health indices.
Source: Central Bureau of Health Intelligence – National Health Profiles 2017 and 2016
CLAIM 18: Only state in India which is open defecation free
Fact: False. Kerala is one of the four states to be counted as open defecation free.
Himachal Pradesh, Kerala, Sikkim and Uttarakhand are open defecation free, according to Swachh Bharat Mission dashboard citing data as of June 16, 2017.
Source: Swachh Bharat Mission Dashboard
CLAIM 19: Only state in India to have electricity in all houses
Fact: False. Four other states have achieved 100% household electrification but Kerala is within a whisker at 99.9%.
Andhra Pradesh, Goa, Punjab and Tamil Nadu are the states with 100% household electrification. These states are followed by Kerala with 99.9% of its households electrified. According to GARV Dashboard, out of 71,03,179 households in Kerala 70,97,455 are electrified with remaining 5,724 households yet to be electrified.
Source : GARV Dashboard
CLAIM 20 : Only Indian state mentioned in National Geographic Channel’s – ‘must watch in a life time’ list
Fact : Though Kerala was the only state mentioned in National Geographic’s ‘ 50 Places of a Lifetime’ , the Taj Mahal, Fatehpur Sikri and Delhi were also listed.
Source : National Geographic
CLAIM 21 : No communal riots for past 75 years
Fact: False. Kerala saw eight communal riots in 2015 and six in 2014, according to National Crime Records.
In 2015, India saw a total of 789 communal riots, with Haryana (201) recording the highest number. In 2014, it was a total of 1227 with the most communal riots in Jharkand (249).
Source : Crime in India 2015, NCRB
CLAIM 22 : No untouchability
Fact : According to National Crime Records, the number of cases recorded under Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 for crimes against Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes are 1 and 0, respectively in 2015.
Protection of Civils Rights Act, 1955 is, ‘An Act to prescribe punishment for the (Preaching and Practice of “Untouchability”) for the enforcement of any disability arising there from and for matters connected therewith’.
Moreover, only 2% of respondents in from Kerala practiced untouchability, according to Indian Human Development Survey 2 ( IHDS 2011 -12) conducted by National Council of Applied Economic Research and University of Maryland, United States. The survey was extended to around 42,000 households in India. As per the survey, 53% of respondents from Madhya Pradhesh practised untouchability, 50% in Himachal Pradesh. The least occurrence of untouchability was in West Bengal (1%).
CLAIM 23: No Dalit oppression
Fact: Kerala recorded a higher rate of crime against Dalits under the Prevention of Atrocities Act than the national crime rate of 19.2.
Though the perception is that Dalit oppression is less heard of in Kerala, according to National Crime Records Kerala recorded a crime rate of 22.9 against Scheduled Caste population under the Prevention of Atrocities Act (POA) in 2015. The national crime rate was 19.2.
The states with highest rate of crimes under POA are Goa (51.1) and Rajasthan (48.4), while the states of Jammu & Kashmir, Manipur, Meghalaya and Mizoram recorded nil.
Here, crime rate refers to the incidence of crime against 1,00,000 of SC population recorded under Prevention of Atrocities Act. However, a high crime rate could also be due to better reporting, registering and policing in states.
Prevention of Atrocities Act is meant to ‘prevent the commission of offences of atrocities against the members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes’.
Source: Crime in India 2015 – NCRB
CLAIM 24: No death in name of cow
FACT: True. While protests over cattle slaughter and consumption of beef have been in the headlines lately, there have been no reported deaths in Kerala due to it.